Skip to resultsNew Game+

What to play next

Games like Overcome Your Fears: Caretaker

2025PC

24 games that share what Overcome Your Fears: Caretaker does well: thriller, first-person and horror. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

  • Father's Day

    2022PC

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    86%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $3.98was $6.99−43%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • From the Darkness

    2021PC

    Linear, walking sim

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $4.19was $6.99−40%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.40/hr

  • Transference

    2018PC · PS · Xbox

    Psychological, walking sim

    Critics
    70
    IGDB
    Players
    70%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    $4.99was $24.99−80%

    Best PC price · Steam · $4.99/hr

    In Game Pass · Ubisoft+ · PS Plus

  • Blair Witch

    2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Psychological, investigation

    Critics
    69
    Metacritic
    Players
    78%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~6h
    IGDB

    $5.07was $29.99−83%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.91/hr

  • Mouthwashing

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $9.09was $12.99−30%

    Best PC price · Steam · $2.60/hr

  • Obey the Voice

    2026PC

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    86%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.39was $7.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • MiSide

    2024PC

    Dialogue heavy, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    97%
    Steam
    To beat
    200h+
    IGDB

    $9.59was $14.99Historical low

    Best PC price · GreenManGaming · $0.02/hr

  • Chilla's Art: The Kidnap

    2023PC

    Thriller, investigation

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    84%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $7.49was $9.99−25%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Dread Neighbor

    2026PC

    Crime, psychological

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    82%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $5.09was $5.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Luto

    2025PC · PS · Xbox

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    83
    Metacritic
    Players
    85%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $11.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $3/hr

  • Terroro

    2024PC

    Thriller, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    82%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    Free

    Free to play

  • Summer of '58

    2021PC

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $4.22was $8.99−53%

    Best PC price · Steam · $2.11/hr

  • Multiplayer

    Cry of Fear

    2013PC

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    88%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    Free

    Free to play

  • Multiplayer

    Phasmophobia

    2020PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Thriller, investigation

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~21h
    IGDB

    $13.99was $19.99−30%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.67/hr

  • The Medium

    2021PC · PS · Xbox

    Psychological, walking sim

    Critics
    75
    IGDB
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~9h
    IGDB

    $10.44was $49.99−79%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.19/hr

  • Karma: The Dark World

    2025PC · PS · Xbox

    Psychological, walking sim

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    90%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $12.99was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • When the Darkness comes

    2019PC

    Psychological, walking sim

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    Free

    Free to play

  • The Beast Inside

    2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Walking sim, thriller

    Critics
    74
    Metacritic
    Players
    83%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~13h
    IGDB

    $2.49was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.19/hr

  • Fears to Fathom: Woodbury Getaway

    2024PC

    Dialogue heavy, crime

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    86%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~60h
    IGDB

    $6.99was $9.99−30%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.12/hr

  • Multiplayer

    Silent Breath

    2026PC

    Thriller, 1990's

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    67%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.99was $9.99−50%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Get Even

    2017PC · PS · Xbox

    Psychological, thriller

    Critics
    75
    Metacritic
    Players
    76%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $3.96was $29.99−87%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.57/hr

  • The Convenience Store

    2020PC · Switch

    Psychological, walking sim

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    82%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $2.24was $2.99−25%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.12/hr