What to play next

Games like Summer of '58

2021PC

24 games that share what Summer of '58 does well: sim, thriller and first-person. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

Father's Day
2022PC
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
86%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$3.98~~was $6.99~~−43%
Best PC price · Steam
Pieces of Me
2025PC
Thriller, linear
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.12~~was $8.99~~−43%
Best PC price · Steam
Don't Scream
2024PC
Linear, walking sim
Critics
unknown
Players
65%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.39~~was $7.99~~−45%
Best PC price · Steam
Dead Signal
2023PC
Realistic, dark
Critics
unknown
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$12.99
Best PC price · Epic Game Store
Night Record: Thin Walls
2026PC
Thriller, cinematic
Critics
unknown
Players
79%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$3.99
Best PC price · Steam
Hellmart
2026PC
Realistic, dark
Critics
unknown
Players
77%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$10.94~~was $14.99~~−27%
Best PC price · Steam
Terroro
2024PC
Thriller, psychological horror
Critics
unknown
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Fears to Fathom: Ironbark Lookout
2023PC · PS
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.99~~was $9.99~~−40%
Best PC price · Steam
No, I'm Not A Human
2025PC · PS · Xbox
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
~5h
IGDB
$11.99~~was $14.99~~−20%
Best PC price · Steam · $2.40/hr
Obey the Voice
2026PC
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
86%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.39~~was $7.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
The Convenience Store
2020PC · Switch
Psychological, walking sim
Critics
unknown
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$2.24~~was $2.99~~−25%
Best PC price · Steam · $1.12/hr
Don't Play This
2026PC
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
84%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$5.84~~was $8.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $5.84/hr
September 7th
2023PC
Psychological, linear
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$3.28~~was $6.99~~−53%
Best PC price · Steam · $3.28/hr
Dread Neighbor
2026PC
Psychological, thriller
Critics
unknown
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.09~~was $5.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Photomaly
2026PC
Mystery, psychological horror
Critics
unknown
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$5.59~~was $6.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $2.80/hr
Luto
2025PC · PS · Xbox
Psychological, thriller
Critics
83
Metacritic
Players
85%
Steam
To beat
~4h
IGDB
$11.99~~was $19.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $3/hr
[Herror] Gas Station Case
2026PC
Thriller, cinematic
Critics
unknown
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$5.39~~was $5.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $2.70/hr
KinitoPet
2024PC
Psychological, linear
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$5.99
Best PC price · Steam · $3/hr
Autopsy Simulator
2024PC · PS · Xbox
Thriller, realistic
Critics
unknown
Players
49%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$7.30~~was $24.99~~−71%
Best PC price · GameBillet
The Painscreek Killings
2017PC
Thriller, walking sim
Critics
unknown
Players
90%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$7.99~~was $19.99~~−60%
Best PC price · Steam
The Complex: Expedition
2025PC
Thriller, cinematic
Critics
unknown
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$14.99
Best PC price · Steam
Mundaun
2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Thriller, cinematic
Critics
72
Metacritic
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.99~~was $19.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Blair Witch
2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Psychological, cinematic
Critics
69
Metacritic
Players
78%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$5.07~~was $29.99~~−83%
Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.91/hr
The Walking Trade
2026PC
Horror, sim
Critics
unknown
Players
85%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$11.99
Best PC price · Steam