Skip to resultsNew Game+

What to play next

Games like Under the Island

2026PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

24 games that share what Under the Island does well: puzzles, RPG and dynamic narration. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

  • Drova: Forsaken Kin

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Dynamic narration, action RPG

    Critics
    78
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $16.24was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Lorelei and the Laser Eyes

    2024PC · PS · Switch

    Puzzles, exploration

    Critics
    88
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~26h
    IGDB

    $9.99was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.38/hr

  • CrossCode

    2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Action RPG, pixel art

    Critics
    86
    Metacritic
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~47h
    IGDB

    $3.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.09/hr

  • Undertale

    2015PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Comedy, pixel art

    Critics
    92
    Metacritic
    Players
    96%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~8h
    IGDB

    $2.49was $9.99−75%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.30/hr

    In PS Plus

  • Five Nights at Freddy's: Into the Pit

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Pixel art, exploration

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~8h
    IGDB

    $13.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.75/hr

  • Forgotton Anne

    2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Fantasy, puzzles

    Critics
    76
    Metacritic
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $1.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.27/hr

  • Minishoot' Adventures

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Open world, fantasy

    Critics
    90
    IGDB
    Players
    97%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $7.49was $14.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

    In Game Pass

  • Immortals Fenyx Rising

    2020PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Historical, action RPG

    Critics
    74
    IGDB
    Players
    73%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~44h
    IGDB

    $3.99was $39.99−90%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.09/hr

    In Game Pass · Ubisoft+ · PS Plus

  • Bastion

    2011PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS

    Dynamic narration, action RPG

    Critics
    86
    Metacritic
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~9h
    IGDB

    $2.99was $14.99−80%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.33/hr

  • Paper Lily: Chapter 1

    2024PC

    Pixel art, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    99%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    Free

    Free to play

  • Webbed

    2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Nature, pixel art

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    97%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~5h
    IGDB

    $5.99was $9.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.10/hr

  • Block Story

    2012PC · iOS · Android

    Action RPG, sandbox

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    85%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $2.49was $4.99−50%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Tunic

    2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Action RPG, fantasy

    Critics
    85
    Metacritic
    Players
    91%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~18h
    IGDB

    $14.99was $29.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.82/hr

    In Game Pass

  • Half Past Fate

    2020PC · Switch

    Comedy, pixel art

    Critics
    78
    Metacritic
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $5.99was $19.99−70%

    Best PC price · Steam · $3/hr

  • Lakeview Cabin Collection

    2015PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Dynamic narration, sandbox

    Critics
    70
    Metacritic
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $0.99was $9.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • The Spiral Scouts

    2018PC

    Comedy, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    90%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~13h
    IGDB

    $1.99was $9.99−80%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.15/hr

  • Fallout 2

    1998PC

    Sandbox, open world

    Critics
    86
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~39h
    IGDB

    $2.15was $9.99−78%

    Best PC price · GreenManGaming · $0.06/hr

    In Game Pass

  • OneShot

    2016PC

    Pixel art, puzzles

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    98%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $5.99was $9.99−40%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.86/hr

  • The Witch's House MV

    2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Pixel art, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $5.99was $14.99−60%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Pentiment

    2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Historical, exploration

    Critics
    88
    Metacritic
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~17h
    IGDB

    $9.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.61/hr

    In Game Pass

  • Heartbound

    2018PC

    Comedy, pixel art

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    52%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $9.99

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Tails of Iron

    2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Action RPG, fantasy

    Critics
    81
    Metacritic
    Players
    87%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~12h
    IGDB

    $2.37was $24.99−91%

    Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.20/hr

  • Baldo: The Guardian Owls

    2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS

    Action RPG, fantasy

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    66%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $19.99

    Best PC price · Steam