What to play next

Games like The Initiate

2017PC

24 games that share what The Initiate does well: psychological horror, puzzles and horror. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

Suite 776
2019PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$1.19~~was $3.99~~−70%
Best PC price · Steam · $1.19/hr
Mouse (Sneaking)
2018PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.49~~was $0.99~~−51%
Best PC price · Steam
The Hat Man: Shadow Ward
2016PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
64%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam
The Mirror Lied
2008PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
Free
Free to play
Blameless
2016PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
83%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
Free
Free to play
I'm on Observation Duty
2018PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$2.39~~was $2.99~~−20%
Best PC price · Steam
The Medium
2021PC · PS · Xbox
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
75
IGDB
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
~9h
IGDB
$10.44~~was $49.99~~−79%
Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.19/hr
Heartbound
2018PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
52%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam
Nyctophobia
2015PC
Horror
Critics
unknown
Players
43%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.99
Best PC price · Fanatical
Hektor
2015PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
55
Metacritic
Players
61%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam
White Day: A Labyrinth Named School
2017PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
72
IGDB
Players
81%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$5.93~~was $29.99~~−80%
Best PC price · GameBillet
Indigo Park
2024PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
Free
Free to play
MiSide
2024PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
200h+
IGDB
$9.59~~was $14.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · GreenManGaming · $0.02/hr
Buddy
2016PC
Horror, story
Critics
unknown
Players
48%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam
Infra
2016PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
88%
Steam
To beat
~24h
IGDB
$7.49~~was $29.99~~−75%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.32/hr
Iris.Fall
2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Horror, puzzles
Critics
70
Metacritic
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~3h
IGDB
$14.99
Best PC price · Steam · $5/hr
Dark Echo
2015PC · iOS · Android
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
unknown
No price yet
Price
2016PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Gevaudan
2017PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
61%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.89~~was $2.99~~−70%
Best PC price · Steam
Little Nightmares II
2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
83
Metacritic
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~5h
IGDB
$8.88~~was $29.99~~−70%
Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.97/hr
Detention
2017PC · PS · Switch · iOS · Android
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
83
Metacritic
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~4h
IGDB
$2.39~~was $11.99~~−80%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.67/hr
Changed
2018PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
88%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.99
Best PC price · Steam
Another Adventure
2017PC
Puzzles
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.99
Best PC price · Steam
Dark Fall: Lost Souls
2009PC
Psychological horror, horror
Critics
75
Metacritic
Players
62%
Steam
To beat
~7h
IGDB
$3.99~~was $9.99~~−60%
Best PC price · GOG · $0.57/hr