Skip to resultsNew Game+

What to play next

Games like Shift at Midnight

2026PC · Xbox

24 games that share what Shift at Midnight does well: horror, sim and first-person. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

  • Multiplayer

    Escape the Backrooms

    2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Stealth, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    90%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $7.99was $9.99−20%

    Best PC price · Steam

    In Game Pass

  • Multiplayer

    Sons of the Forest

    2024PC

    Survival horror, horror

    Critics
    78
    OpenCritic
    Players
    88%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~35h
    IGDB

    $8.69was $29.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.25/hr

  • Dead Signal

    2023PC

    Psychological horror, horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $12.99

    Best PC price · Epic Game Store

  • Multiplayer

    Backrooms: Escape Together

    2026PC · PS · Xbox

    Survival horror, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    88%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $7.49was $9.99−25%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    Pacify

    2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Survival horror, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    86%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~6h
    IGDB

    $2.14was $4.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.36/hr

  • Rewind or Die

    2023PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Stealth, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $7.19was $11.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • No, I'm Not A Human

    2025PC · PS · Xbox

    Choices matter, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~5h
    IGDB

    $11.99was $14.99−20%

    Best PC price · Steam · $2.40/hr

  • Multiplayer

    Demonologist

    2023PC

    Investigation, detective

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    85%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $5.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    Don't Scream Together

    2025PC

    1990's, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    49%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.39was $7.99−45%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • The Complex: Expedition

    2025PC

    1990's, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $14.99

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Zoochosis

    2024PC · PS · Xbox

    Detective, 1990's

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    60%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $10.74was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $3.58/hr

  • Multiplayer

    No More Room in Hell 2

    2026PC · PS · Xbox

    Survival horror, online co-op

    Critics
    79
    Metacritic
    Players
    62%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $17.55was $29.99−41%

    Best PC price · GameBillet

  • Multiplayer

    Night Shippers

    2026PC

    Stealth, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    74%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.79was $7.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    Buckshot Roulette

    2023PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Psychological horror, horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    $1.79was $2.99−40%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.79/hr

    In Game Pass

  • Photomaly

    2026PC

    Investigation, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $5.59was $6.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $2.80/hr

  • Multiplayer

    Content Warning

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Investigation, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    200h+
    IGDB

    $3.89was $7.99−51%

    Best PC price · AllYouPlay · $0/hr

  • While We Wait Here

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Interactive fiction, choices matter

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $3.49was $4.99−30%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.16/hr

  • Multiplayer

    In Silence

    2020PC

    Stealth, survival horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    75%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $3.99was $9.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    Eyes: The Horror Game

    2013PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Interactive fiction, stealth

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    90%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $0.99was $4.99−80%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    The Blackout Club

    2019PC · PS · Xbox

    Stealth, survival horror

    Critics
    64
    IGDB
    Players
    78%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $14.99was $29.99−50%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Hellmart

    2026PC

    Survival horror, choices matter

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    77%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $10.94was $14.99−27%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • September 7th

    2023PC

    1990's, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    87%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    $3.28was $6.99−53%

    Best PC price · Steam · $3.28/hr

  • Parasocial

    2023PC

    Investigation, 1990's

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $5.99was $7.99−25%

    Best PC price · Steam · $2/hr

  • That's Not My Neighbor

    2024PC

    Choices matter, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    88%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $2.99

    Best PC price · Steam · $1/hr