Skip to resultsNew Game+

What to play next

Games like Pony Island

2016PC

24 games that share what Pony Island does well: horror, puzzles and hacking. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

  • Silence of the Sleep

    2014PC

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    66
    Metacritic
    Players
    77%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~6h
    IGDB

    $0.69was $4.99−86%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.12/hr

  • Imscared

    2016PC · Android

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $1.99was $3.99−50%

    Best PC price · GOG · $1/hr

  • Lucius II

    2015PC

    Demons, dark

    Critics
    48
    Metacritic
    Players
    61%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $14.69was $19.99−27%

    Best PC price · Fanatical

  • Welcome to the Game

    2016PC

    Hacking, dark

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    84%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.99

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Haunt the House: Terrortown

    2010PC · iOS

    Psychological horror, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    87%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $0.99was $4.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • The Consuming Shadow

    2015PC

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $0.49was $0.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Limbo

    2010PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Short, dark

    Critics
    88
    Metacritic
    Players
    91%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $1.24was $12.49−90%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.34/hr

    In Game Pass · EA Play

  • Cyber Manhunt

    2021PC

    Hacking, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $3.39was $9.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • The Good Time Garden

    2019PC

    Experimental, short

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    Free

    Free to play

  • Home Sweet Home

    2017PC · PS · Xbox

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    88%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $13.59was $16.99−20%

    Best PC price · Fanatical

  • S.p.l.i.t

    2025PC

    Hacking, short

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $1.94was $2.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • I'm on Observation Duty

    2018PC

    Psychological horror, horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $2.39was $2.99−20%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Mad Father

    2012PC · Switch

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    97%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $4.99was $9.99−50%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Multiplayer

    Buckshot Roulette

    2023PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Experimental, dark

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~1h
    IGDB

    $1.79was $2.99−40%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.79/hr

    In Game Pass

  • Visage

    2020PC · PS · Xbox

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    81
    Metacritic
    Players
    84%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $22.74was $34.99−35%

    Best PC price · Steam · $3.13/hr

  • Distraint

    2015PC

    Short, dark

    Critics
    76
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $0.69was $4.99−86%

    Best PC price · GOG · $0.23/hr

  • Little Inferno

    2012PC · Switch · iOS · Android

    Short, dark

    Critics
    68
    Metacritic
    Players
    96%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $4.94was $14.99−67%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.20/hr

  • Dreaming Sarah

    2015PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Pixel art, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $1.79was $5.99−70%

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Bulb Boy

    2015PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Short, dark

    Critics
    84
    Metacritic
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $0.89was $8.99−90%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.40/hr

  • Stories Untold

    2017PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    81
    Metacritic
    Players
    86%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $0.93was $9.24−90%

    Best PC price · GamesPlanet UK · $0.31/hr

  • Paper Lily: Chapter 1

    2024PC

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    99%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    Free

    Free to play

  • Devotion

    2019PC

    Horror, puzzles

    Critics
    89
    IGDB
    Players
    83%
    IGDB
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    No price yet

  • Scorn

    2022PC · PS · Xbox

    Dark, psychological horror

    Critics
    63
    IGDB
    Players
    77%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~6h
    IGDB

    $8.61was $39.99−78%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.42/hr