What to play next

Games like Nightmare Reaper

2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

24 games that share what Nightmare Reaper does well: horror, arcade and retro shooter. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

Demon Pit
2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
66%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.49~~was $8.99~~−50%
Best PC price · Steam
Cultic
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
unknown
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam · $1.67/hr
Forgive Me Father 2
2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, dark
Critics
unknown
Players
81%
Steam
To beat
~9h
IGDB
$9.99~~was $24.99~~−60%
Best PC price · Steam · $1.11/hr
Hrot
2023PC
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
unknown
Players
96%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$6.79~~was $19.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Multiplayer
Dusk
2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
88
Metacritic
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$5.99~~was $19.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.96/hr
Stay Out of the House
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Old school, 1990's
Critics
unknown
Players
94%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$8.99~~was $14.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Infliction
2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Surreal, dark
Critics
unknown
Players
80%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$3.99~~was $19.99~~−80%
Best PC price · Steam
Choo-Choo Charles
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Dark, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
~3h
IGDB
$6.19~~was $19.99~~−69%
Best PC price · Steam · $2.06/hr
Coven
2024PC
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$8.99~~was $14.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Multiplayer
Doom II: Hell on Earth
1994PC
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
83
Metacritic
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~20h
IGDB
No price yet
Multiplayer
Prodeus
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, FPS
Critics
84
Metacritic
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$12.49~~was $24.99~~−50%
Best PC price · Steam · $2.08/hr
Multiplayer
SCP: Secret Laboratory
2017PC
FPS, psychological horror
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
200h+
IGDB
Free
Free to play
Multiplayer
Blood: Fresh Supply
2019PC
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
77
Metacritic
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Gamesload
Multiplayer
Sven Co-op
1999PC
1990's, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Cruel
2025PC
Retro shooter, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$6.99~~was $9.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
Crossbow: Bloodnight
2020PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
73%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.74~~was $2.99~~−75%
Best PC price · Steam
Zombeer
2014PC · PS
FPS, shooter
Critics
32
Metacritic
Players
72%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.99
Best PC price · Steam
Quake II RTX
2019PC
Retro shooter, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Vomitoreum
2021PC
Retro shooter, surreal
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$7.49~~was $9.99~~−25%
Best PC price · Steam · $3.43/hr
Devil Daggers
2016PC
Dark, FPS
Critics
83
Metacritic
Players
96%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$3.39~~was $9.99~~−66%
Best PC price · Steam
Wrath: Aeon of Ruin
2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro shooter, old school
Critics
72
Metacritic
Players
75%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.99~~was $24.99~~−80%
Best PC price · GOG
Multiplayer
Unturned
2017PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Looter shooter, FPS
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
~60h
IGDB
Free
Free to play
Multiplayer
F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin
2009PC
FPS, psychological horror
Critics
79
Metacritic
Players
83%
Steam
To beat
~12h
IGDB
$2.26~~was $14.99~~−85%
Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.19/hr
Painted In Blood
2025PC
Retro shooter, surreal
Critics
unknown
Players
83%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$7.99~~was $9.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam