Skip to resultsNew Game+

What to play next

Games like Mayor May Knott

2026PC

24 games that share what Mayor May Knott does well: puzzles, thriller and kids. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

  • Subject 13

    2015PC · PS · Xbox

    Thriller, mystery

    Critics
    59
    Metacritic
    Players
    54%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $1.56was $9.99−84%

    Best PC price · GameBillet

  • Sally Face

    2016PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    97%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~10h
    IGDB

    $2.99

    Best PC price · Humble Store · $0.30/hr

  • Donut County

    2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Comedy, kids

    Critics
    77
    Metacritic
    Players
    91%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~2h
    IGDB

    $2.48was $12.99−81%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.16/hr

    In Game Pass

  • What Remains of Edith Finch

    2017PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    89
    Metacritic
    Players
    95%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $3.88was $19.99−81%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.53/hr

  • Out of Sight

    2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $6.99was $9.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.75/hr

  • Unforeseen Incidents

    2018PC · Switch

    Mystery, comedy

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    87%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $11.99was $19.99−40%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.71/hr

  • Multiplayer

    Reanimal

    2026PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    78%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~6h
    IGDB

    $29.99was $39.99−25%

    Best PC price · Steam · $5/hr

  • Tormented Souls

    2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Old school, thriller

    Critics
    75
    Metacritic
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~15h
    IGDB

    $4.29was $19.99−79%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.29/hr

  • Murdered: Soul Suspect

    2014PC · PS · Xbox

    Thriller, dark

    Critics
    59
    Metacritic
    Players
    87%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~8h
    IGDB

    $1.99was $19.99−90%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.27/hr

  • The Gardens Between

    2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Mystery, puzzles

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $7.99was $19.99−60%

    Best PC price · Steam · $2.21/hr

    In PS Plus

  • A Little to the Left

    2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Cozy, kids

    Critics
    75
    Metacritic
    Players
    91%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~5h
    IGDB

    $4.45was $14.99−70%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.87/hr

    In PS Plus

  • Carto

    2020PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Kids, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    96%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $5.99was $19.99−70%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.92/hr

  • Little Nightmares

    2017PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Thriller, dark

    Critics
    81
    Metacritic
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $4.46was $19.99−78%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.23/hr

  • Indika

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~5h
    IGDB

    $6.74was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Fanatical · $1.31/hr

    In Game Pass · PS Plus

  • Slender Threads

    2025PC · Switch · iOS · Android

    Thriller, dark

    Critics
    80
    Metacritic
    Players
    90%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $9.99was $19.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Don't Escape: 4 Days to Survive

    2019PC

    Mystery, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    98%
    Steam
    To beat
    unknown

    $2.99was $14.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam

  • Strange Horticulture

    2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Cozy, dark

    Critics
    83
    Metacritic
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~7h
    IGDB

    $4.79was $15.99−70%

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.66/hr

  • Boxes: Lost Fragments

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android

    Mystery, puzzles

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    92%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~5h
    IGDB

    $8.24was $14.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.83/hr

  • The Medium

    2021PC · PS · Xbox

    Thriller, dark

    Critics
    75
    IGDB
    Players
    89%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~9h
    IGDB

    $10.44was $49.99−79%

    Best PC price · GameBillet · $1.19/hr

  • Fear the Spotlight

    2024PC · PS · Xbox · Switch

    Old school, third-person

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    96%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~4h
    IGDB

    $13.99was $19.99−30%

    Best PC price · Steam · $3.50/hr

  • Darq

    2019PC · Xbox · Switch

    Dark, mystery

    Critics
    unknown
    Players
    94%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~3h
    IGDB

    $3.99was $19.99−80%

    Best PC price · Steam · $1.34/hr

  • Lorelei and the Laser Eyes

    2024PC · PS · Switch

    Mystery, puzzles

    Critics
    88
    Metacritic
    Players
    93%
    Steam
    To beat
    ~26h
    IGDB

    $9.99was $24.99Historical low

    Best PC price · Steam · $0.38/hr