What to play next

Games like Five Nights at Candy's

2015PC

24 games that share what Five Nights at Candy's does well: strategy, mystery and horror. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

Paratopic
2018PC
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
72%
IGDB
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$4.99
Best PC price · Steam
Baldi's Basics Classic Remastered
2022PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
unknown
Free
Free to play
Stigmatized Property
2019PC
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
80%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$2.24~~was $2.99~~−25%
Best PC price · Steam
Inscryption
2021PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Mystery, horror
Critics
85
Metacritic
Players
96%
Steam
To beat
~16h
IGDB
$7.99~~was $19.99~~−60%
Best PC price · GamesPlanet US · $0.51/hr
In Game Pass
Blue Prince
2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Mystery, strategy
Critics
92
Metacritic
Players
85%
Steam
To beat
~22h
IGDB
$15.11~~was $29.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · GreenManGaming · $0.70/hr
In Game Pass · PS Plus
At Dead of Night
2020PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
94%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$15.99
Best PC price · Steam
Siren
2003PS
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
70%
IGDB
To beat
unknown
See priceon PlayStation Store
Also in PS Plus Premium
Multiplayer
Buckshot Roulette
2023PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
95%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$1.79~~was $2.99~~−40%
Best PC price · Steam · $1.79/hr
In Game Pass
Devastation
2003PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
50%
IGDB
To beat
~9h
IGDB
No price yet
Your Turn to Die: Death Game by Majority
2017PC
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~26h
IGDB
$13.59~~was $16.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $0.52/hr
Berry Bury Berry
2026PC · PS · Switch
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
98%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$5.59~~was $7.99~~−30%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.93/hr
Baldi's Basics Plus
2020PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$9.99
Best PC price · Steam
Multiplayer
R.E.P.O.
2025PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
96%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$6.49~~was $9.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
The Closing Shift
2022PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
$4.49~~was $5.99~~−25%
Best PC price · Steam · $2.25/hr
Multiplayer
SCP: Secret Laboratory
2017PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
91%
Steam
To beat
200h+
IGDB
Free
Free to play
The Suicide of Rachel Foster
2020PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Mystery, horror
Critics
65
IGDB
Players
69%
Steam
To beat
~4h
IGDB
$1.43~~was $17.99~~−92%
Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.36/hr
Multiplayer
Dead Realm
2015PC
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
62%
Steam
To beat
unknown
No price yet
Ghostwire: Tokyo
2022PC · PS · Xbox
Mystery, horror
Critics
77
Metacritic
Players
83%
Steam
To beat
~27h
IGDB
$14.99~~was $59.99~~−75%
Best PC price · Nuuvem · $0.56/hr
In Game Pass
Multiplayer
Pacify
2019PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Horror, strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
86%
Steam
To beat
~6h
IGDB
$2.14~~was $4.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $0.36/hr
Chaos Zero Nightmare
2025PC · iOS · Android
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
4.9/5
App Store
To beat
unknown
No price yet
Anatomy
2016PC
Horror, first-person
Critics
unknown
Players
85%
IGDB
To beat
unknown
No price yet
Ratshaker
2024PC · PS · Xbox
Mystery, horror
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
$1.79~~was $2.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Fanatical · $1.79/hr
Cult of the Lamb: Cultist Edition
2022PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Strategy
Critics
unknown
Players
71%
IGDB
To beat
~30h
IGDB
$29.98
Best PC price · GOG · $1/hr
Monument Valley
2014PC · iOS · Android
Mystery, strategy
Critics
90
IGDB
Players
4.8/5
App Store
To beat
~3h
IGDB
$2.79~~was $7.99~~−65%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.93/hr