What to play next

Games like Between Me and the Night

2016PC

24 games that share what Between Me and the Night does well: fantasy, 1990's and retro. Each one shows critic and player scores, how long it takes to beat, and the cheapest way to play it today.

Tune these picks

Add more games you loved, filter by platform or price, and set your Game Pass, PS Plus or Apple Arcade.

24 picks · prices checked daily

Lilly Looking Through
2013PC
Point & click, retro
Critics
71
Metacritic
Players
76%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.99~~was $9.99~~−80%
Best PC price · GOG
The Dark Eye: Memoria
2013PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
1990's, point & click
Critics
79
Metacritic
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
~9h
IGDB
$1.59~~was $19.99~~−92%
Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.18/hr
Dragonsphere
1994PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
unknown
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.04~~was $6.99~~−85%
Best PC price · Steam
The Curse of Monkey Island
1997PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
89
Metacritic
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~8h
IGDB
$3.49~~was $6.99~~−50%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.42/hr
Celeste
2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Retro, fantasy
Critics
88
Metacritic
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~21h
IGDB
$4.99~~was $19.99~~−75%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.23/hr
In PS Plus
Missing Translation
2015PC
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~1h
IGDB
Free
Free to play
Silver
1999PC
1990's, retro
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.97~~was $5.99~~−67%
Best PC price · Steam
Axel & Pixel
2009PC
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
unknown
Players
70%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$1.24~~was $4.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam
The Book of Unwritten Tales
2009PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
82
Metacritic
Players
90%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$4.17~~was $19.99~~−79%
Best PC price · GamesPlanet US
Finding Teddy
2013PC · iOS
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
unknown
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.62~~was $6.99~~−91%
Best PC price · Fanatical
Multiplayer
Shadow Fight 2
2014Switch · iOS · Android
Fantasy, side-scrolling
Critics
unknown
Players
4.8/5
App Store
To beat
unknown
See priceon Nintendo eShop
Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis
1992PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
unknown
Players
93%
Steam
To beat
~12h
IGDB
$2.99~~was $5.99~~−50%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.24/hr
Candle
2016PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
80
Metacritic
Players
78%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.79~~was $4.99~~−84%
Best PC price · Steam
Maniac Mansion
1987PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
unknown
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~3h
IGDB
$2.09~~was $5.99~~−65%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.70/hr
The Inner World
2013PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android
1990's, point & click
Critics
72
Metacritic
Players
87%
Steam
To beat
~7h
IGDB
$1.19~~was $14.99~~−92%
Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.17/hr
Sonic the Hedgehog
1991PC · iOS
1990's, retro
Critics
unknown
Players
85%
Steam
To beat
~2h
IGDB
No price yet
The Longing
2020PC · Switch · Android
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
79
Metacritic
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~33h
IGDB
$10.49~~was $14.99~~Historical low
Best PC price · Steam · $0.32/hr
Morphopolis
2014PC
Point & click, puzzles
Critics
unknown
Players
82%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$0.79~~was $3.99~~−80%
Best PC price · Steam
Multiplayer
Dead Cells
2018PC · PS · Xbox · Switch · iOS · Android
Fantasy, side-scrolling
Critics
89
Metacritic
Players
97%
Steam
To beat
~22h
IGDB
$11.18~~was $24.99~~−55%
Best PC price · GameBillet · $0.51/hr
In PS Plus
The Longest Journey
1999PC · iOS
1990's, point & click
Critics
91
Metacritic
Players
89%
Steam
To beat
~20h
IGDB
$2.44~~was $9.99~~−76%
Best PC price · Fanatical · $0.12/hr
Loom
1990PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
unknown
Players
90%
Steam
To beat
unknown
$2.99~~was $5.99~~−50%
Best PC price · Steam
Grimvalor
2018Switch · iOS · Android
Fantasy, side-scrolling
Critics
unknown
Players
4.9/5
App Store
To beat
unknown
See priceon Nintendo eShop
Leila
2025PC · PS · Xbox · Switch
1990's, point & click
Critics
82
Metacritic
Players
86%
Steam
To beat
~4h
IGDB
$11.99
Best PC price · GOG · $3/hr
The Dig
1995PC
1990's, point & click
Critics
unknown
Players
92%
Steam
To beat
~9h
IGDB
$1.19~~was $5.99~~−80%
Best PC price · Steam · $0.13/hr